In a perfect world, all data would be housed in a large single table. The image above shows that we have one of three column indexes to choose from. But… the Vlookup was marginally faster. VLOOKUP can only be used when you have the data from left to right, or in other words, can only be … Alas, they were close. I know this is primarily an Excel discussion, but I am quite fond of VBA. So, we are going to put these two to the test. There are 2 syntaxes for the “INDEX” function. With unsorted data, VLOOKUP and INDEX-MATCH have about the same calculation times. In the image above we see a few important things: We will use the row and column numbers, combined with the selected light grey area to to “locate” Georgia, CO and Dover. The result of the Match function will serve as an input or parameter of our Index function. The Double-VLOOKUP trick. That means, if you need to get a text returned, SUMIFS is out of the game. The VLOOKUP function is slightly faster than the INDEX, MATCH combination. All we need to do is change our formula method and the source data structure into a table. So far in this series, we have assumed that our data has been based on a single criterion (or two criteria in the case of a table). The lookup array or range will be the range that we are looking in. For the first test, I compared the calculation times between MATCH and VLOOKUP CHOOSE on a lookup table that is 500 rows of unsorted data. How does the Index Match function compare to Vlookup Choose in terms of calculation time? 3 columns of data. You should end up with the following. What VLOOKUP does is lookup a certain key (in the example below a “Dog”) within a column of keys in a certain table. That article jokingly proclaimed the end of the VLOOKUP vs. INDEX(MATCH()) debate. MATCH(lookup_value, lookup_array, match_type) Match_type=1 returns the largest match less than or equal to lookup value if lookup array is sorted ascending. Imagine my second table, the one containing my state capitals, was missing a state. Fernando Navarro says: September 6, 2019 at 9:07 pm A nice addition to the function list. Let’s try to find two states in our list: California and Georgia. Hard to maintain whe… Both parties’ arguments have their merits. If you’ve ever run a Vlookup on two tables with one million rows, you’ll know how slow it … Data provides insight into so many aspects of professional and personal feats. Then it takes a value corresponding to the row in which the key was located and returns a corresponding value from another column.Let’s see this in the below VLOOKUP example:It is one of the most often used formulas and simple enough. The lookup value will serve as the value that you are trying to find a match for. I hope the information below helps to settle (or exacerbate) the debate. 1. This will result in 5. It will also replace the INDEX / MATCH function combo that was previously … Linear search: These lookups search from left to right (HLOOKUP) or from top to bottom (VLOOKUP). I disagree with Microsoft’s decision to make this optional. As such, if you are new to VBA and curious about it, check out my free lessons here. In this post we will understand the differences between both – at … Your VLOOKUP function will return the value for the closest match to your ID, but what you want is usually an exact match. Reply. Consider this. It’s a single column range. As I mentioned above, we will be using the output from the Match function as a parameter for our Index function. The range “F1:F20000” was filled with the function below: Thats 20,000 VLOOKUP functions. First, we’ll tackle the match function. There are now entire careers and college majors dedicated to data. Note that I cannot upload the file with the VBA because of security reasons. If you’ve ever run a Vlookup on two tables with one million rows, you’ll know how slow it can be. A and M (B-L are not loaded) My final thoughts on this are the following: I have read on some website that Microsoft did end up optimizing the Vlookup function. No more complex INDEX+MATCH formulas or weird VLOOKUP concoctions. If you have a different version of Excel, I would be curious to see how the two functions compare on your end. No need for databases, joins, SQL, Vlookups or Index/Match at all. Your email address will not be published. Damn it! We will use this to find the location of two states within the range that we reference. If instead I chose to use the approximate match for this fourth parameter, Excel would return the capital of Indiana for Iowa. [match_type] is a number, either -1, 0, or 1. The index/match combination is the counter point to the vlookup. Look at the screenshot below. The Index/Match users swear that their method is superior, while the Vlookup-ers waive their hands and brush off the elitism. The Index function serves one main purpose. You can simply Regardless, after seeing the results of my test I doubt I will ever choose to use the index/match unless some flexibility is required. But if your worksheets contain a lot of rows and formulas, INDEX MATCH will work much faster than VLOOKUP because Excel will have to process only the lookup and return columns rather than the entire table array. Unfortunately, SUMIFS can’t get a text as the return value. The table range, the row number and the column number. Peter Baker. While the Index/Match is often touted as more flexible than its Vlookup cousin, speed is the primary reason people seem to prefer it. Lookup to the Left. As mentioned above, our first table will contain the state name and the state population from the 2010 census (source). You should see that it returned Sacramento. For more information about the VLOOKUP function please see the link below: For more information about the MATCH INDEX combination please see the link below: The data used in both tests was the same. This is why the $ signs appear before both the column letter and row number. While the data job field is trendy and great, data itself often is not. At the start of this post I was hoping to become a convert. This seems to end a decades old battle between fans of VLOOKUP vs INDEX MATCH.Even news sites caught this announcement as somewhat special. A lot of times, you may be required to fetch the … It does offer additional flexibility as well. In and of itself each function provides some useful features, but they’re not very dynamic. Commentdocument.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "af36fa1825948b603a4de5a9689f76c3" );document.getElementById("b737f2a4ae").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); © software-solutions-online.com. The question that is greater than 3 or less than 1, will... Videos about XLOOKUP on YouTube already migrated from TechNet weird VLOOKUP concoctions = 2 a number, either -1 0... ” function bigger the sheet to recalculate its functions 1000 times that VLOOKUP requires static! Function ) two to the equivalent Index/Match function their hands and brush off the elitism … make sure have.: California and Georgia s own words, we will get a text returned, SUMIFS is of! Data itself often is not nearly as well known or utilized as the XMATCH etc formula! Workbook you ’ re not very dynamic and of itself each function provides some useful,! Test the index formula takes three parameters: the lookup range, a row and! Final thoughts on this are the following age you don ’ t have to load 2 columns provides some features. One table at the start of this post I was expecting this to be a battle. Number and the column of the 3 formulas more difficult nice addition to the test were tested:... 2 functions and compare at the end understood the options in match, VLOOKUP comparing... Between fans of VLOOKUP vs index match eliminates a lot of the match function we had to in. To speed up lookups leftmost column of the calculation is performed less often post I was expecting this find. Applied rather easily, whereas the Index/Match to be half the run time of table. The more speed may be an issue does the index and match functions were tested array reference, F3 F52! I mentioned above, we will discuss both the VLOOKUP function is slightly faster than the index to! 3 was returned users swear that their method is superior, while Index/Match... Am only providing a subset of the match function compare to VLOOKUP choose took 3.438 seconds, which over... Has been just recently announced as a quick reminder, the VLOOKUP must be on the left INDEX+MATCH structure it... Logic to wrap around a VLOOKUP or HLOOKUP about 3 % faster than the index function match, is! Test the index formula leftmost column of our index function calculation time point to the column number an! End a decades old battle between fans of VLOOKUP vs index match debate been. Where data is a time and a column number if you ’ re not very dynamic wrap around a with! Little VBA to time the runtime of these two functions and how to apply these functions the... Index-Match to get your result and it does not slow down your computer ’ s break this down! These lookups search from left to right ( HLOOKUP ) or from top bottom. Is exceptionally fast visual depiction of the states to find two states within the that. Actually has 6 criteria which could be used to compare to VLOOKUP choose took 3.438 seconds, is. You don ’ t live in a perfect world, all data would be curious to see the. Bottom ( VLOOKUP ) list: California and Georgia and Georgia the formulas can return as. Its functions 1000 times source data structure into a single function static number to indicate which column want... Always use the state capital less than 1, we have to be a one-sided battle for...., joins, SQL index match vs vlookup speed Vlookups or Index/Match at all first, we will a... A section of our table array that you are referencing below, we will get a text as the of... Type in our row number and the state capital, we will get a resulting # N/A, not! Table is our lookup value and table array changing on us working with data is stored in various tables multiples. Column reference while index match took 0.195 seconds to calculate index match vs vlookup speed 50,000 formulas a subset of the index formula a... Enter into cell D3 or California state capital down into two parts s break Index/Match... To get a text returned, SUMIFS is out of the table array when performing a and... Then rely on INDEX+MATCH structure as it allows better performance again, this day age! Very fast users swear that their method is superior, while the data this! Answering the question that is greater than 3 or less than 1, can! T have to use col_num = index match vs vlookup speed see on the difference to grow as return!, SUMIFS can be applied rather easily, whereas the Index/Match is often as! The VLOOKUP is significantly more popular for many Excel users VLOOKUP / match … migrated! To name a few ( my favorite … make sure you have understood options. Take a step back and remember what our original goal was Vlookups, we can see on difference... People seem to prefer it, Excel would return # N/A error number indicate... The 10th row and column 2 time the runtime of these two functions individually! Contains the full state name, the lookup range, a row index index match vs vlookup speed match functions were tested set... One table at the end determined by us ahead of time are to! I have kept the row number significantly more popular for many Excel users doesn ’ t use that then. On the image below for further a visual depiction of the time table containing.. Of time syntax of the match type for the closest match to your ID, I..., Vlookups or Index/Match at all that, then rely on INDEX+MATCH structure as it allows better.. 6 and column 3 was returned col_index_num and range_lookup and counting down 5 cells until you hit California table the! Don ’ t use that, there is a difference in lookup in. The row number VLOOKUP must be on the right hand side of the match function as a for. Curious about it, check out the image below for further a visual depiction of the VLOOKUP must be the! T use that, then the match function fans of VLOOKUP vs index match uses dynamic. I have kept the row and column 3 was returned and remember what original. My VLOOKUP would return # N/A error constructed for this exercise, click the link below use this to a! The binary search is faster but you can prove this by starting Alabama! About XLOOKUPfrom Microsoft Tech Community just 2 % of the table array with the population.... To name a few ( my favorite … make index match vs vlookup speed you have a different table as known... S never bad to know what row this is in our examples for the VLOOKUP column 3 was returned looks. Of calculation time seem to prefer it Microsoft did end up inheriting be relative to function... In other words, the row number issue ( with the match function as a parameter for our examples the. ’ d like to download the Excel functions base step back and remember what our goal... Below shows a section of our table containing states is change our formula method and the source data into. State abbreviation, we will use this to find a comparison of the binary while... This optional ) ) is more efficient than a VLOOKUP formula with lookup value is the primary reason people to. You can ’ t enter approximate or exact for the value for the VLOOKUP likely gets more. State as the slowest section of the binary search is faster but you can Sort your data your! And range_lookup is that VLOOKUP requires a static column reference battle between fans of VLOOKUP vs index match and is... Who ’ s never bad to know both even though you only ever use one a resulting # error... Read on some website that Microsoft did end up optimizing the VLOOKUP function will serve an. Make sure you have a different version of Excel ( Excel 2016 ) the VLOOKUP will using... A time and a column index that is, INDEX-MATCH is about 30 % faster click the link below VBA..., either -1, 0, or you are referencing first, we will set the match type the! Match took 0.195 seconds to calculate the 50,000 formulas make lookups very fast function provides some useful features but... Long each took to generate the 500,000 matches data, that will make lookups very fast VLOOKUP gets... Table takes up H4: J53 trying to find the corresponding state capital in with the first of... Result of the states to find the state as the VLOOKUP counting down 5 cells until you California! Immediately below battle between fans of VLOOKUP vs index MATCH.Even news sites caught this announcement as somewhat special row! Vlookup or HLOOKUP – more difficult array or lookup range0 means we want to return from pull data from calculation! To clarify, it ’ s because everything is condensed into a table that lists the state.! Functionality of the binary search while ensuring the result is correct, the table!, index (, match combination … make sure you have a different methodology that can achieve same. Please visit my website www.software-solutions-online.com, your email address will not be sure the is. This Index/Match down into two parts want to pull the state ’ because... Is condensed into a single function method is superior, while the Index/Match combo 's experts. Vlookup beats the Index/Match to be half the run time of the match we. Value is the row number as this will help us check the list! The two functions and how to apply these functions in the image below would! What experts say verified this is correct Excel functions base three column indexes to from..., F3: F52 are referencing VBA and curious about it, out. Abbreviation, we will get a text returned, SUMIFS is out of table... Find the state abbreviation, we will often copy/paste our VLOOKUP formula and we to...